Showing posts with label Reason. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reason. Show all posts

Tuesday, 2 June 2026

The Law of Karma vs. Vasudeva Sarvam Iti

Question: 

I was blessed to hear from you on Savitri, the Secret Knowledge

(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=897NveFwhKY).

I truly believe that "Vasudev sarvam iti. He is the doer, and he is the deed. He is the actor, and he is the act. Srasta bhi wo hai, sristi bhi wo hi hai.  Man is only an instrument of the divine Will. When man does everything as per the instructions of the divine, then why should he suffer? Where do the questions of bad karma, good karma, karma phala, and karmic debt come from?  When one goes through a difficult time, then very often he is told "aap ko karma phala bhogtana padega". When I did nothing, then how am I supposed to suffer? Kindly enlighten.

Warm Regards,

A Sadhak of Savitri.

 

Reply:

“वासुदेवः सर्वम् इति" (श्रीमद्भगवद्गीता-०७/१९) - यह सकल जगत् ईश्वर ही है।

“Vasudev Sarvam Iti” means that the whole of this world is God, i.e., He is the Creator and the Creation; He is the Actor, and the act; He is the Dreamer and the dream; He is the Thinker and the thought. It is He alone who has become man. So, it is very natural to ask how a man is responsible for his acts when God is working through him, and what the justification for this law of Karma and Fate is. 

It will be appropriate to recall the first verse of the Sri Aurobindo Upanishad, which says -

“ॐ एकमेव अदिवितीयम् ब्रह्म सदसद्रूपं सदसद्तीतं नान्यत् किन्च्चिदस्ति त्रिकालधृतं त्रिकालातीतं वा सर्वन्तु खलु ब्रह्मैकं यत किन्च्च ज्गत्यामणु वा महेद्वोदारं वानुदारं वा ब्रह्मैव तद् ब्रह्मैव जगदपि ब्रह्म सत्यं न मिथ्या।“ (श्रीअरविन्दोपनिषद्:, verse-1)

Which means: “Om. There is Brahman alone, the One without a second. Being and non-being are its forms and It is also beyond Being and Non-Being. There is nothing else except That. All that is contained in the three times and all that is beyond the three times is indeed that One Brahman alone. Whatever is in the universe, small or large, noble or mean, is Brahman alone, Brahman alone. The world is also Brahman. It is true, not false.” 

In the Sri Aurobindo Upanishad, Sri Aurobindo says, “ॐ एकमेव अदिवितीयम् ब्रह्म and जगदपि ब्रह्म सत्यं न मिथ्या”, that is, all this is God, and there is nothing in this world which is other than God. This world is also God, and it is real. 

To understand the above problem, let’s now go through three examples -

 

Example-1)  

          Consider the realities of the awakened and dream states.

 

Both the realities of the awakened world and the dream world are true. However, when we are awake, the dream appears to us false, and when we are in a dream, the awakened world appears to us untrue. However, both are true in their own domains, but when we look at them from outside the domain in which they exist, they appear false to us.

 

When we are in the real world, we forget the dream world, and when we are in the dream world, we forget the real world, and therefore, one of the two realities appears to us as false.

 

The real problem is not that one or both observations are untrue, but that we are not able to rise to a world where both worlds appear in their proper place and in harmony with each other, and therefore, we are not able to see that both these observations are true.

 

Yet if we can take a higher position from which we can see both, we will find that both are real.


 

Example-2)   


 Consider the realities of Earth and Heaven.

 

        We all have heard about the glory of heaven, and many a man has attempted to reach heaven. Some of them, having reached heaven and being wonderstruck by its glory, came down and professed the path to heaven which they found, declared that the glory of heaven is not reachable on earth, and advocated leaving the earth as it is and working to enjoy heaven.

 

The reality of the Earth is not false; we know this, for we live here, while heaven is imaginary for us because we have no access to it. But heaven is not false - the reality of heaven is true in heaven, and the reality of earth is true on earth. So long as we are bound to earth, heaven appears false to us. Perhaps, for those who live in heaven, earth is false. It is only for those who can live both on earth and in heaven, transcend both earth and heaven, and can harmonise between earth and heaven, that both earth and heaven are true.

 

It is only when we can transcend earth and heaven and establish harmony between the two that we can find that both are real.

 

But why is it so?

 

In the cosmic lila, things have been so arranged that we get glimpses of the beauties of a higher world, but we can’t enjoy them unless we change and transcend our present limits. If it were so that we could enjoy heaven while living on earth, there would be no urgency to change earth, and earth would have remained the same for eternity. It is an evolutionary necessity, which entices us with glimpses of the glories of the higher world but does not let us enjoy them unless we change ourselves and become rightful claimants of those riches. This incompleteness and corresponding dissatisfaction force us to participate in evolution.


 

Example-3)   


         Consider a room which is closed from the inside, and you are trapped in it. But it is only you who has, in a moment of unconsciousness, closed the room from inside and hid the key somewhere inside the room. 


         Now, if you don’t know that you closed the room and also have the key to unlock it, you feel trapped in it. But the moment you remember that you have the key, you realise that you are in fact free. So, the feeling of freedom or imprisonment depends only on your memory. (Once we realise who we are and are able to recover our ‘smriti’ (स्मृति), we are no longer entrapped in the world or the body.)

 

Freedom and imprisonment are both real. So long as we do not have the smriti (memory), who we are, we are under the subjection of Nature and feel imprisoned, and the moment we get our smriti (memory) back, we become free and the masters of Nature.

 

        So, freedom and imprisonment are both true, but what we experience depends on the state of our consciousness.

 


Coming back to your question –

 

         The Law of Karma and Fate are true in the domain we live in, and the truth of “Vasudev Sarvam Iti” is true in a domain of perfect unity. Both seem contradictory, but both are simultaneously true.

 

God, being Omniscient, Omnipotent, and Absolute, can assume both states simultaneously. The Absolute, the Alone, and the All-Powerful can become One as well as Many simultaneously. But man bound by Reason thinks that the two are opposites and can’t exist together.

 

          So long as we live in human consciousness, we are governed by the Law of Karma and Fate; it is only when we rise much above this divided world to a world in which there is perfect unity and only One, that “Vasudev Sarvam Iti” is true.

 

        Even if the fundamental truth is “Vasudev Sarvam Iti”, it is only the Law of Karma and Fate that are applicable to us. So long as man is bound to human ignorance, he can’t claim the privileges of the world of unity. 


This is the cosmic lila; if it weren’t so, man would not feel himself entrapped and suffocated and never try to escape the human consciousness, and the whole plan of evolution would fail.

 

Not only that, a light, a beauty, a bliss from the highest region of creation enters our world and creates discontent among some. It is this discontentment which forces them to rise and find their truth. And the whole of humanity advances with them.

 

This is the hidden Divine Plan!

 

 

 

Thursday, 18 December 2025

God and His Relationship with the World – A Problem Beyond the Human Mind

A few days back, we had a long discussion in a whatsapp group on God and the World. It ended without any consensus. But why? Why do we always fail to reach any conclusion on such topics?

1) There are many definitions of God and His relationship with the World, but none of                    them can be proved, because

  • The definition of God and His relationship with the World lie in a non-physical (or a non-material) domain, which is beyond the purview of present-day science.
  • Further, whatever the human mind constructs, it is always based on a set of assumptions. Since these assumptions vary from person to person, the definition of God and His relationship with the World varies from person to person.
2) Thus, people have different definitions of God and His relationship with the World, as per their own preferences. This is natural and absolutely fine, but the real problem arises when a person believes that his system is perfect and all others are incorrect or partly correct. Or when he believes that his worldview is better than others’. This is a problem of human psychology: we are imprisoned in our own worldview and unable to see things from another’s standpoint.

  • For our worldviews are a result of our observations/ our experiences, the depth of our reasoning, and our affinity to a particular worldview. Our worldviews are different because we are different in all these aspects.

3) The right attitude, then, should be that all these definitions of God and His relationship with the World are our own choices. None is better than the other, for each one is simply a hypothesis that can’t be proved.

4) An important learning that arises out of this discussion is that whatever our beliefs are, they are simply our choices, which cannot be proved. Just as we have made one choice, we are free to make another. So, our approach should be, not to condemn any worldview but to realise that all of them are simply hypotheses. We shall learn to treat them as equals. If we want to pursue a particular worldview, it is simply our choice; it doesn't make us wiser than others.

5) A still more important issue is, are we happy with our worldview?
  • If so, we may continue with whatever we believe in.   
  • If not, we shall be ready to change our worldview. We may revisit our experiences, examine our conclusions, and explore and rework our affinities, for whatever worldview we have is simply a borrowed vesture and not us. 

 

For we are born free, but as we grow, we are entrapped in the norms, rituals, conventions, opinions, etc, of the world around us. Once we understand this, we shall strive to live freely unbound by any worldview, and choose a worldview that appears to us right at the moment. And we shall be ready to change or modify our worldview the moment we find flaws in it, for all our worldviews are borrowed worldviews and not our true beings.

Reality is vaster than Mind and always escapes its reach.


Note: You may join this blog by clicking the tab "Follow" at the top right of the blog.

Sunday, 19 November 2023

Quote: Limited Mind, Unlimited World


Limited Mind, Unlimited World

It is not that the wonders of the world are limited; it is our vision* that is limited.

(for example, we only see a part of the spectrum; the world exists beyond both ends of the visible spectrum.)

The irony is we don't see our limitations; instead, we impose them on what we see.


(* Our vision includes our perception, conception, and our imagination. In a sense, it means our mind.)

Sunday, 5 November 2023

A Journey from Faith to Reason

 A Journey from Faith to Reason 


A Journey from Faith to Reason

a is a journey from 

'All is Meaningful' to 'All is Meaningless'.


Date: 05/11/2023

Saturday, 4 November 2023

A Journey from Reason to Faith

 

A Journey from Reason to Faith 


A Journey from Reason to Faith

a is a journey from 

'All is Meaningless' to 'All is Meaningful'.


Date: ~22/10/2023


Friday, 30 October 2020

Reason and Belief in God

October 30, 2020.
  • Whatever we have a been living with becomes normal to us. Whatever violates common sense and experience and seems impossible, becomes a limitation on us. This sense of possible and impossible takes the form of a law.
  • All laws of physics and logic of mathematics are formulations of our own experiences – our possibilities and our limitations, as perceived by us.
  • These laws are true so long as we are bound and unaware of our boundaries. For example, a) 2+2=4, is true so long as the law of conservation of mass holds, and b) Newton’s law of gravitation was true, so long we were moving slow.
  • These laws are nothing but our own creation. Down the line we lose the sight of this relationship - we forget that we are the creators of our laws and start thinking that the laws are supreme and govern us.
  • A belief that this world is a machine and follows certain fixed laws, is a belief. It is quite possible that someday these laws may change – who has seen the future?
  • A belief that Sun would rise in the east because it has been doing so for ages, is a belief. Someday earth may change its rotation - why not?
  • Whatever law is working today will continue to work same tomorrow, is a projection – all projections and inferences are beliefs.
  • Disbelief in God is of our own creation - there is no law or logic which denies the existence of God. Those who do not believe in the magic do not believe in God and those who believe in the magic believe in God. For God is nothing but a ‘Magic’ which transcends all laws (i.e. our limitations).
  • In reality, everything is a wonder – creation of the world, the evolution of life, the evolution of mind, the law of gravitation, etc. all are a wonder – there is no reason for them to be there except by a miracle. There is no law which says gravitation shall be there; there is no law which says that energy and mass shall be interconvertible.
  • You may believe in science or in the laws of nature, if that suits you. On the contrary, you may believe in magic, if it suits you. Either way, it is a belief.
  • Science neither denies nor affirms God – it only puts the human experiences in mathematical formulations.
  • Finally, whether you believe in God or you do not believe in God, is your Choice. Both are beliefs - there is no science, nor any logic in it. Don't fall into the self-gratifying illusion that being an atheist is being rational. 

Note: If you wish, you can follow my blog by sharing your email at the appropriate box at top right or at the bottom. Once you have subscribed to this blog, you will get automatic notifications as an when a new article is posted in this blog.

October 30, 2020. Excerpts of the discussion on this issue, between 'X' and 'I' elsewhere: 

X: I am an atheist based on arguments for or against the existence of God.
I: As if arguments are complete in themselves. If you look dispassionately, all arguments are based on faith.
X: Based on evidence and logic, neither is faith.
I:  2+2=4 is faith. I hope this makes sense.
X: No it doesn't. How is mathematical logic, faith?
I: Wrote the above Blog.
X: 
Fair enough. There is no scientific proof of non-existence of God. But this is similar to Bertrand Russell's teapot, small invisible in orbit between Earth and Mars around the Sun. If you do not believe it is there, the burden of non-existence proof is on you.
I prefer the scale formulated by Richard Dawkins 1 being a believer and 7 being an atheist. I am about 6. There is an utter lack of evidence. Hence, it is not faith, but a lack of evidence that suggests that the probability of God's existence is very low. I rest my case.

I: "If you do not believe it is there, the burden of non-existence proof is on you." No, it is your problem - if you want to prove God is not there - it is your problem; if nobody has been able to prove the non-existence of God, you must prove it, because you want proof. But if you want to believe God is not there, it is perfectly fine, - you are free to believe whatever you want to.
"Richard Dawkins 1 being a believer and 7 being an atheist. I am about 6." Wherever you are on this scale - it is your belief. What I am saying that you can't escape believing - even science is a belief. I am not arguing for or against the existence of God, I am simply saying wherever you place yourself, it is a belief. so both believer and non-believer are on the same footing.


 

Tuesday, 18 December 2018

Some Thoughts - Spirituality, Man and his Life, Man and Society

Spirituality:

  • Peace is not an absence of noise, disturbances or activity. Peace exists in itself. One can be peaceful in the midst of most violent action.
  • Happiness is not a state of physical comforts, satisfied desires or harmony of thoughts. Happiness exists in itself. One can be happy in the midst of all that is the cause of unhappiness.
  • Being purposeless, thoughtless, and silent is a great achievement but if one can simultaneously keep faith in the Almighty, surrender to Him, and be ready to receive and change, he has completed his part of the job; rest all is that of God’s.
  • It is not an empty “Nothingness” it is a pregnant “Shunya” and that is not all.
  • God doesn’t live aloof in heaven. He is there within us, around us, knocking at our doors, eager to meet us. We only need to listen to His cries.


Man and his Life:

  • Unless the goal is known, we can’t evaluate our progress. Unless we know the destination we don’t know if we have moved closer to our destination or farther from our destination.
  • The only job man has on this earth is to know the purpose of his life. If we don’t know the purpose of our life, the first thing we need to do is to know the purpose of our life, all else is a foolish movement.
  • The only job a man has on this earth is to silence his mind. Unless his mind is silent, he is a slave of this thoughts.
  • The only difference between a man and an animal is that man can work consciously to know himself.
  • No analysis can predict the future nor it can help you choose the aim of your life. The aim of life is always a choice, however, one can choose the path to attain the aim of his life, analytically.


Man and Society:

  • Men can rarely keep their subjective and objective beings separate. In any interaction, they bring in subjectivity which forms a curtain/filter, at times this curtain/filter continues in future conversations. We shall learn to isolate our judgement from our subjectivity.
  • There is a commonsense one can term as crowd-wisdom. It is a result of the experiences of innumerable individuals of different ages from different circumstances with wide experiences. It may not help one fly but it will also not let him sink. It is a result of the aspirations of the crowd, i.e. to live a peaceful life w/o much problems. One shall not defy crowd-wisdom unless one has a strong will power - a will -power that can withstand the headwinds – a will-power that can give the strength to face the challenges. 
  • Some people we have to bear for whole life, we can’t wish them away. You can insulate yourself from them to an extent.

Friday, 13 October 2017

A Poetic Dialogue between an Egoistic and a Pure Mind


I am a rational man; I know all.
I know the gravitational law. “Not the little why.”
I know the energy law. “Not the tiny why.”
I work with the body. “And forget the hidden heart.”
I know all. “But a subtle why.”

“One day the distant ‘Cipher’ will devour all,
Yet you dare not.”

The ‘cipher’ is far n small, I can ignore.
I know all, I can sermon all.
I am the king, I live like a king.

“Only till the ‘child’ is awake again.”  
“Only if Nature has done all.”  

Notes:
‘Cipher’ is ‘Death’ that takes away all that we have earned and accumulated throughout our life.

‘child’ is the feeble pure reasoning mind that is hushed by the dominant egoist mind which is a slave to fears, needs, desires, pleasures, preferences, and ideals. The child grows with time. 

Text in double quotes is the voice of the frail but pure reasoning mind.

Friday, 15 July 2016

Reason and Beyond

Reason and Beyond

Date: 21-11-15


A long struggle comes to an end. Reason that was supported by science all along, has been conquered. The country it had usurped is reclaimed. A new Light descends; Reason learns to cooperate and obey its rule. A goal has been achieved. 

But an Aryan does not stop here, journey and the struggle continues. Aspiration to unveil the Absolute burns more intensely, now. The path is better lit, distant goals are clearer and a new struggle has begun. The territory is unknown, the milestones are difficult and higher, struggle more intense, but the spirit's will is invincible; faith is the guide and the shield. 

March ahead, be sure Truth will prevail.