Showing posts with label Freedom. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Freedom. Show all posts

Tuesday, 2 June 2026

The Law of Karma vs. Vasudeva Sarvam Iti

Question: 

I was blessed to hear from you on Savitri, the Secret Knowledge

(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=897NveFwhKY).

I truly believe that "Vasudev sarvam iti. He is the doer, and he is the deed. He is the actor, and he is the act. Srasta bhi wo hai, sristi bhi wo hi hai.  Man is only an instrument of the divine Will. When man does everything as per the instructions of the divine, then why should he suffer? Where do the questions of bad karma, good karma, karma phala, and karmic debt come from?  When one goes through a difficult time, then very often he is told "aap ko karma phala bhogtana padega". When I did nothing, then how am I supposed to suffer? Kindly enlighten.

Warm Regards,

A Sadhak of Savitri.

 

Reply:

“वासुदेवः सर्वम् इति" (श्रीमद्भगवद्गीता-०७/१९) - यह सकल जगत् ईश्वर ही है।

“Vasudev Sarvam Iti” means that the whole of this world is God, i.e., He is the Creator and the Creation; He is the Actor, and the act; He is the Dreamer and the dream; He is the Thinker and the thought. It is He alone who has become man. So, it is very natural to ask how a man is responsible for his acts when God is working through him, and what the justification for this law of Karma and Fate is. 

It will be appropriate to recall the first verse of the Sri Aurobindo Upanishad, which says -

“ॐ एकमेव अदिवितीयम् ब्रह्म सदसद्रूपं सदसद्तीतं नान्यत् किन्च्चिदस्ति त्रिकालधृतं त्रिकालातीतं वा सर्वन्तु खलु ब्रह्मैकं यत किन्च्च ज्गत्यामणु वा महेद्वोदारं वानुदारं वा ब्रह्मैव तद् ब्रह्मैव जगदपि ब्रह्म सत्यं न मिथ्या।“ (श्रीअरविन्दोपनिषद्:, verse-1)

Which means: “Om. There is Brahman alone, the One without a second. Being and non-being are its forms and It is also beyond Being and Non-Being. There is nothing else except That. All that is contained in the three times and all that is beyond the three times is indeed that One Brahman alone. Whatever is in the universe, small or large, noble or mean, is Brahman alone, Brahman alone. The world is also Brahman. It is true, not false.” 

In the Sri Aurobindo Upanishad, Sri Aurobindo says, “ॐ एकमेव अदिवितीयम् ब्रह्म and जगदपि ब्रह्म सत्यं न मिथ्या”, that is, all this is God, and there is nothing in this world which is other than God. This world is also God, and it is real. 

To understand the above problem, let’s now go through three examples -

 

Example-1)  

          Consider the realities of the awakened and dream states.

 

Both the realities of the awakened world and the dream world are true. However, when we are awake, the dream appears to us false, and when we are in a dream, the awakened world appears to us untrue. However, both are true in their own domains, but when we look at them from outside the domain in which they exist, they appear false to us.

 

When we are in the real world, we forget the dream world, and when we are in the dream world, we forget the real world, and therefore, one of the two realities appears to us as false.

 

The real problem is not that one or both observations are untrue, but that we are not able to rise to a world where both worlds appear in their proper place and in harmony with each other, and therefore, we are not able to see that both these observations are true.

 

Yet if we can take a higher position from which we can see both, we will find that both are real.


 

Example-2)   


 Consider the realities of Earth and Heaven.

 

        We all have heard about the glory of heaven, and many a man has attempted to reach heaven. Some of them, having reached heaven and being wonderstruck by its glory, came down and professed the path to heaven which they found, declared that the glory of heaven is not reachable on earth, and advocated leaving the earth as it is and working to enjoy heaven.

 

The reality of the Earth is not false; we know this, for we live here, while heaven is imaginary for us because we have no access to it. But heaven is not false - the reality of heaven is true in heaven, and the reality of earth is true on earth. So long as we are bound to earth, heaven appears false to us. Perhaps, for those who live in heaven, earth is false. It is only for those who can live both on earth and in heaven, transcend both earth and heaven, and can harmonise between earth and heaven, that both earth and heaven are true.

 

It is only when we can transcend earth and heaven and establish harmony between the two that we can find that both are real.

 

But why is it so?

 

In the cosmic lila, things have been so arranged that we get glimpses of the beauties of a higher world, but we can’t enjoy them unless we change and transcend our present limits. If it were so that we could enjoy heaven while living on earth, there would be no urgency to change earth, and earth would have remained the same for eternity. It is an evolutionary necessity, which entices us with glimpses of the glories of the higher world but does not let us enjoy them unless we change ourselves and become rightful claimants of those riches. This incompleteness and corresponding dissatisfaction force us to participate in evolution.


 

Example-3)   


         Consider a room which is closed from the inside, and you are trapped in it. But it is only you who has, in a moment of unconsciousness, closed the room from inside and hid the key somewhere inside the room. 


         Now, if you don’t know that you closed the room and also have the key to unlock it, you feel trapped in it. But the moment you remember that you have the key, you realise that you are in fact free. So, the feeling of freedom or imprisonment depends only on your memory. (Once we realise who we are and are able to recover our ‘smriti’ (स्मृति), we are no longer entrapped in the world or the body.)

 

Freedom and imprisonment are both real. So long as we do not have the smriti (memory), who we are, we are under the subjection of Nature and feel imprisoned, and the moment we get our smriti (memory) back, we become free and the masters of Nature.

 

        So, freedom and imprisonment are both true, but what we experience depends on the state of our consciousness.

 


Coming back to your question –

 

         The Law of Karma and Fate are true in the domain we live in, and the truth of “Vasudev Sarvam Iti” is true in a domain of perfect unity. Both seem contradictory, but both are simultaneously true.

 

God, being Omniscient, Omnipotent, and Absolute, can assume both states simultaneously. The Absolute, the Alone, and the All-Powerful can become One as well as Many simultaneously. But man bound by Reason thinks that the two are opposites and can’t exist together.

 

          So long as we live in human consciousness, we are governed by the Law of Karma and Fate; it is only when we rise much above this divided world to a world in which there is perfect unity and only One, that “Vasudev Sarvam Iti” is true.

 

        Even if the fundamental truth is “Vasudev Sarvam Iti”, it is only the Law of Karma and Fate that are applicable to us. So long as man is bound to human ignorance, he can’t claim the privileges of the world of unity. 


This is the cosmic lila; if it weren’t so, man would not feel himself entrapped and suffocated and never try to escape the human consciousness, and the whole plan of evolution would fail.

 

Not only that, a light, a beauty, a bliss from the highest region of creation enters our world and creates discontent among some. It is this discontentment which forces them to rise and find their truth. And the whole of humanity advances with them.

 

This is the hidden Divine Plan!

 

 

 

Saturday, 7 June 2025

Being Selfish – Collectivity to Individuality to Being One and Many Simultaneously

 Being Individual is a Natural Step in Earth’s Evolution:

The purpose of animal life was to preserve its species and make it available as a stable and secure platform for future evolution.

Man, too, is a laboratory for future evolution. But the purpose of man is twofold – i.e., to preserve humanity to provide a secure base for future evolution, and to support the evolution by expressing inherent multiplicity. Being individual is a natural step in the Earth’s evolution. Selfishness is only a faster means of achieving the same.

Being Individual is to Fulfil the Purpose of Nature:

The Purpose of Nature is to express ‘One to Many’ (एकोऽहं बहुस्याम्). This is the law that governs the world. ‘One’ can’t manifest itself in ‘Many’ without individuality. Therefore, being individual is the logical, natural and underlying urge of Nature.

Being Individual is to be Happy:

In all his movements, Man seeks happiness. But he can’t be happy unless there is harmony between what he is within and that which he is outside. To express what one is within is to be an individual, and a right step towards being happy.

Collectivity vs Individuality:

Systems, such as family, society and organisations, have their own egos. In general, they are more concerned about their own existence, structure, and dominance than individuals’ (their constituents’) happiness, and build themselves at the expense of the individuals. This apathy forces man to revolt and break away from the systems, create their own world, and nourish their individuality. The efforts towards individuality are termed selfishness. However, selfishness is an unrefined urge to explore and express oneself.

It is only in the process of becoming an individual that a man will realise his true being and the relevance of systems. Individuality and collectivity are both important. They support each other and should grow together. Any effort by one to dominate the other is going to invite pushback.

Moving from self-centred collectivity to self-centred individuality, humanity will attain harmony between them, because, at least in the present environment where we are largely interdependent, none can live without the other. This, then, shall lead to a stage in which systems and individuals will become equally important and mutually beneficial.

Man is an Individual and All, simultaneously:

Selfishness is one of the means by which human evolution is progressing from Collectivity to Individuality. However, superficial individuality, - an individuality devoid of universality, is not going to bring permanent happiness to man either, because man is essentially universal. He is a soul, which is nothing but a part and the Whole.

ॐ पूर्णमदः पूर्णमिदं पूर्णात् पूर्णमुदच्यते। पूर्णस्य पूर्णमादाय पूर्णमेवावशिष्यते।

अर्थ: बाह्य जगत् पूर्ण है, आंतरिक जगत् भी पूर्ण है, पूर्ण से पूर्ण प्रकट होता है, पूर्ण में से पूर्ण लेने पर भी पूर्ण ही शेष रहता है।

He must move from collectivity to individuality to being ‘One’ and ‘Many’ simultaneously.

Human Evolution:

Man, however, when he appears selfish (individualistic) in his actions, he still lives by the collective mentality. This movement towards individuality should grow until it brings mental independence or mental individuality.

Evolution will not stop until man grows truly individual. It is then that he will realise true Unity.

It is then that the Earth and Man will achieve Unity that is simultaneously blissful Multiplicity.

Concluding Note:

Selfishness is not something to be condemned. It is a force working for the evolution of mankind. Man, who has been largely living in a group at the cost of his individuality, shall break apart to seek his individuality. It is only when he becomes truly Individual that he will become truly Universal.

‘One to Many’ (एकोऽहं बहुस्याम्) is the law of the Earth and the law of Evolution.

Selfishness is currently the force that is pushing for this movement. We may term it an evil force from the standpoint of a distant ideal of Harmony, but at the current level of humanity, it is doing its work perfectly fine.

Sunday, 1 December 2024

Don't Let Your Thoughts Determine Your Limits.

 Don't Let Your Thoughts Determine Your Limits.

Unless a person distinguishes between himself and his ideas, opposition to his ideas will hurt him and give rise to a conflict or hostility between him and the aggressor.

Our thoughts are like our clothes. When our clothes are torn, worn out, dirty, or tight or loose we should throw them off. But if they fit us well, we should not care what others opine about them.

We are not our clothes. Our clothes are not our identity. We have changed our clothes many a time in the past. There is no harm in changing them once more if they bring greater harmony to our lives.

Thoughts are just a means of expression. They are not us. As we change, so do our thoughts. Don't stick to your thoughts. Don't let your thoughts define your limits.


जब कोई व्यक्ति अपने आप और अपने विचारों के मध्य भेद नहीं करता, तब उसके विचारों का विरोध उसे आहत करता है और कभी-कभार उसका वैचारिक विरोध करने वाले उसका शत्रु बन जाता है।

हमारे विचार हमारे वस्त्रों के समान हैं। अगर हमारे वस्त्र फट गए हैं, घिस गए हैं, गंदे हो गए हैं, तंग होगे हैं, अथवा ढीले हो गए हैं, तो हमें उन्हें उतार फेंकना चाहिए। परन्तु यदि हमारे वस्त्र हमें ठीक लग रहे हैं, तो इस बात की चिंता किये बिना कि दूसरे उनके बारे में क्या कह रहे हैं हमें उन्हें धारण किए रहना चाहिए।

हम हमारे वस्त्र नहीं हैं; हमारे वस्त्र हमारी पहचान नहीं हैं। भूतकाल में हमने कई बार अपने वस्त्र बदले हैं। अब यदि उनके बदलने से हमारा जीवन और अधिक सामंजस्यपूर्ण हो रहा है तो उन्हें एक बार पुन: बदलने में कोई बुराई नहीं है।

विचार अभिव्यक्ति का साधन मात्र हैं। वे हम नहीं हैं। जैसे-जैसे हम बदलते हैं वैसे-वैसे हमारे विचार भी बदलते हैं, उन्हें बदलना ही चाहिये। अपने विचारों से चिपके न रहें। अपने विचारों को अपनी सीमाएं निर्धारित न करने दें।

 

Saturday, 20 March 2021

A Birthday Wish


A Birthday Wish

 

Far from the struggling world,
Beyond the dreams of harmony and happiness,
Free from the will and efforts of life,
There is I, within, unknown to us.
May this day you stop a while;
Turn inward in silence towards that light,-
Immutable, eternal, it waits there for us in a sea of bliss.

Friday, 30 October 2020

Reason and Belief in God

October 30, 2020.
  • Whatever we have a been living with becomes normal to us. Whatever violates common sense and experience and seems impossible, becomes a limitation on us. This sense of possible and impossible takes the form of a law.
  • All laws of physics and logic of mathematics are formulations of our own experiences – our possibilities and our limitations, as perceived by us.
  • These laws are true so long as we are bound and unaware of our boundaries. For example, a) 2+2=4, is true so long as the law of conservation of mass holds, and b) Newton’s law of gravitation was true, so long we were moving slow.
  • These laws are nothing but our own creation. Down the line we lose the sight of this relationship - we forget that we are the creators of our laws and start thinking that the laws are supreme and govern us.
  • A belief that this world is a machine and follows certain fixed laws, is a belief. It is quite possible that someday these laws may change – who has seen the future?
  • A belief that Sun would rise in the east because it has been doing so for ages, is a belief. Someday earth may change its rotation - why not?
  • Whatever law is working today will continue to work same tomorrow, is a projection – all projections and inferences are beliefs.
  • Disbelief in God is of our own creation - there is no law or logic which denies the existence of God. Those who do not believe in the magic do not believe in God and those who believe in the magic believe in God. For God is nothing but a ‘Magic’ which transcends all laws (i.e. our limitations).
  • In reality, everything is a wonder – creation of the world, the evolution of life, the evolution of mind, the law of gravitation, etc. all are a wonder – there is no reason for them to be there except by a miracle. There is no law which says gravitation shall be there; there is no law which says that energy and mass shall be interconvertible.
  • You may believe in science or in the laws of nature, if that suits you. On the contrary, you may believe in magic, if it suits you. Either way, it is a belief.
  • Science neither denies nor affirms God – it only puts the human experiences in mathematical formulations.
  • Finally, whether you believe in God or you do not believe in God, is your Choice. Both are beliefs - there is no science, nor any logic in it. Don't fall into the self-gratifying illusion that being an atheist is being rational. 

Note: If you wish, you can follow my blog by sharing your email at the appropriate box at top right or at the bottom. Once you have subscribed to this blog, you will get automatic notifications as an when a new article is posted in this blog.

October 30, 2020. Excerpts of the discussion on this issue, between 'X' and 'I' elsewhere: 

X: I am an atheist based on arguments for or against the existence of God.
I: As if arguments are complete in themselves. If you look dispassionately, all arguments are based on faith.
X: Based on evidence and logic, neither is faith.
I:  2+2=4 is faith. I hope this makes sense.
X: No it doesn't. How is mathematical logic, faith?
I: Wrote the above Blog.
X: 
Fair enough. There is no scientific proof of non-existence of God. But this is similar to Bertrand Russell's teapot, small invisible in orbit between Earth and Mars around the Sun. If you do not believe it is there, the burden of non-existence proof is on you.
I prefer the scale formulated by Richard Dawkins 1 being a believer and 7 being an atheist. I am about 6. There is an utter lack of evidence. Hence, it is not faith, but a lack of evidence that suggests that the probability of God's existence is very low. I rest my case.

I: "If you do not believe it is there, the burden of non-existence proof is on you." No, it is your problem - if you want to prove God is not there - it is your problem; if nobody has been able to prove the non-existence of God, you must prove it, because you want proof. But if you want to believe God is not there, it is perfectly fine, - you are free to believe whatever you want to.
"Richard Dawkins 1 being a believer and 7 being an atheist. I am about 6." Wherever you are on this scale - it is your belief. What I am saying that you can't escape believing - even science is a belief. I am not arguing for or against the existence of God, I am simply saying wherever you place yourself, it is a belief. so both believer and non-believer are on the same footing.


 

Friday, 9 October 2020

Opinions, Conflicts, Ego, and the Real ‘I’

 (A letter to IITD-82 Bachelors – a WhatsApp Group)

 Let us Disrobe Ourselves and find the Real Self

This write-up refers to a post in response to X’s on this forum suggesting that we should not post controversial messages on this forum.

Pardon me, I differ: Do we really want to limit this group to jokes and memories of hostel days? If we do so, will any vitality and purpose be left in the group?

Our environment has changed - we need to change: Almost all that we liked during IIT days is no longer relevant to us now. Even the warmth we feel when we meet now is short-lived. I have seen those meetings – they are full of joy for a while, but the joyous moments do not last for long. We have all changed with time; our tastes, preferences, and constraints have changed. Therefore, we need to change our ways – old ways and old memories no longer have the same attraction and thrill.

Virtual groups are large and diverse, and we have grown old, stiff, and wise. Therefore, ego clashes are natural: In pre-social-media days at IIT, our groups were small, and we had the choice of choosing and changing our friends. Moreover, we were still in the learning process. Therefore, the conflicts were less, and we could go along well within a small group. But things have changed now. Our social group is large and diverse - it encompasses all – even those who differ and contradict. Moreover, we have grown old and wise - there is hardly anything left to learn or worth learning. Therefore, ego clashes on the Whatsapp group are but natural.

We are different and limited – there is still much to learn: Instead of blocking the irritant and sleeping comfortably in our cocoons, we need to learn, change, and grow with time, for - 

a)     Our knowledge and experiences are limited, both in time and space. 

b)     Our friends, social groups, books, and other sources of information are limited. 

c)     Our ideals, goals, preferences, and concerns are different. 

d)     Our heritage - religion, language, and caste etc are different.  

Thus, our perceptions, conclusions, and opinions are spontaneously different. Knowing that we are all limited and different, we must continue to remind ourselves that perhaps I do not know the Truth, perhaps my idea is not the supreme. Or it is enough, it is all – we have reached the peak.

If there are higher peaks, we need to follow some rules: If we are aware of our limitations, this group can be quite beneficial to us for we can learn from others what escaped our attention. But for that, we must follow a few rules. 

a)     We shall not presume that one who is opposing our views is casting aspersions on us. He is simply putting his views on the table. We can accept or reject his views. 

b)     When somebody shares his views, we need not condemn it, outcast it or drown it. We can accept or reject his views. 

Perhaps, we have noted that any conversation has many ingredients – information, analysis, opinion, and an effort to dominate or justify oneself. All this is mixed and rides in involuntarily on our words. We need to be vigilant – we can enrich ourselves with the information, learn from the logic and ignore the opinion and the ego content.

Thus, if we do not take things personally, avoid being touchy, and keep our emotions under check, we can avoid conflicts. In turn, we can learn much from the opposite and annoying that we had missed or not accounted for.  

Let us not wear a blind: What ‘X’ shared might have hurt some, but I think what he did was right. It was an eye-opener, at least for me – I came to know of a harsh reality which I did not know before - of course, I had to contain my emotions to view the video; nevertheless, it was informative. It is for us to accept or reject what is shared – but to stop anyone from sharing his views – I think it is to imprison oneself. 

Share with an equanimous mind: But how should one, who is sharing anything, operate – he should do so with an equanimous mind and simply share his experience and knowledge without condemning or opposing anyone else's views, without a sense of superiority for all that we know is incomplete and imperfect.

Can we go back to ragging days and disrobe ourselves - we will find the Real ‘I’: Beyond this exchange of information and opinions, there is something more fundamental that we must not forget – i.e. we are different from our opinions. This is one basic fact which we always tend to forget, and it is the major cause of all conflicts. 

a)     We were neither born with a view nor we will die with the view we possess now. 

b)  We picked up the view we have now in the course of life, we are changing even now, albeit unknowingly, and we will continue to change in future. This is what life is – ever-changing, ever-growing. The moment we stop changing, we die. Then why are we stuck up with any view?

Once you know that you are different from your opinion, you will find that behind the change and growth there is something that remains fixed - that is the awareness of oneself – the Real ‘I’.

Love thy opponent: The day we understand that we are different from our opinions, the problem of conflicts of opinions will be automatically resolved. No more we will associate our opinions with our real ‘I’. No more we would hear the undertone of ‘holier than thou’ or ‘brighter than thou’. Instead, I would love my opponent for he gave me a chance to unrobe, enlarge, and move nearer to Real ‘I’.

Note: If you wish, you can follow my blog by sharing your email at the appropriate box at top right or at the bottom. When you follow this blog, you will get automatic notifications as an when a new article is posted in this blog.

Tuesday, 18 December 2018

Some Thoughts - Spirituality, Man and his Life, Man and Society

Spirituality:

  • Peace is not an absence of noise, disturbances or activity. Peace exists in itself. One can be peaceful in the midst of most violent action.
  • Happiness is not a state of physical comforts, satisfied desires or harmony of thoughts. Happiness exists in itself. One can be happy in the midst of all that is the cause of unhappiness.
  • Being purposeless, thoughtless, and silent is a great achievement but if one can simultaneously keep faith in the Almighty, surrender to Him, and be ready to receive and change, he has completed his part of the job; rest all is that of God’s.
  • It is not an empty “Nothingness” it is a pregnant “Shunya” and that is not all.
  • God doesn’t live aloof in heaven. He is there within us, around us, knocking at our doors, eager to meet us. We only need to listen to His cries.


Man and his Life:

  • Unless the goal is known, we can’t evaluate our progress. Unless we know the destination we don’t know if we have moved closer to our destination or farther from our destination.
  • The only job man has on this earth is to know the purpose of his life. If we don’t know the purpose of our life, the first thing we need to do is to know the purpose of our life, all else is a foolish movement.
  • The only job a man has on this earth is to silence his mind. Unless his mind is silent, he is a slave of this thoughts.
  • The only difference between a man and an animal is that man can work consciously to know himself.
  • No analysis can predict the future nor it can help you choose the aim of your life. The aim of life is always a choice, however, one can choose the path to attain the aim of his life, analytically.


Man and Society:

  • Men can rarely keep their subjective and objective beings separate. In any interaction, they bring in subjectivity which forms a curtain/filter, at times this curtain/filter continues in future conversations. We shall learn to isolate our judgement from our subjectivity.
  • There is a commonsense one can term as crowd-wisdom. It is a result of the experiences of innumerable individuals of different ages from different circumstances with wide experiences. It may not help one fly but it will also not let him sink. It is a result of the aspirations of the crowd, i.e. to live a peaceful life w/o much problems. One shall not defy crowd-wisdom unless one has a strong will power - a will -power that can withstand the headwinds – a will-power that can give the strength to face the challenges. 
  • Some people we have to bear for whole life, we can’t wish them away. You can insulate yourself from them to an extent.

Saturday, 27 January 2018

The Importance of Studying India's Great Past - Swami Vivekananda

"Those whose only aim is to barter the energies of life for gold, or name, or any other enjoyment; those to whom the tramp of embattled cohorts is the only manifestation of power; those to whom the enjoyments of the senses are the only bliss that life can give — to these, India will ever appear as an immense desert whose every blast is deadly to the development of life, as it is known by them.

But to those whose thirst for life has been quenched for ever by drinking from the stream of immortality that flows from far away beyond the world of the senses, whose souls have cast away — as a serpent its slough — the threefold bandages of lust, gold, and fame, who, from their height of calmness, look with love and compassion upon the petty quarrels and jealousies and fights for little gilded puff-balls, filled with dust, called "enjoyment" by those under a sense-bondage; to those whose accumulated force of past good deeds has caused the scales of ignorance to fall off from their eyes, making them see through the vanity of name and form — to such wheresoever they be, India, the motherland and eternal mine of spirituality, stands transfigured, a beacon of hope to everyone in search of Him who is the only real Existence in a universe of vanishing shadows.

The majority of mankind can only understand power when it is presented to them in a concrete form, fitted to their perceptions. To them, the rush and excitement of war, with its power and spell, is something very tangible, and any manifestation of life that does not come like a whirlwind, bearing down everything before it, is to them as death. And India, for centuries at the feet of foreign conquerors, without any idea or hope of resistance, without the least solidarity among its masses, without the least idea of patriotism, must needs appear to such, as a land of rotten bones, a lifeless putrescent mass.

It is said — the fittest alone survive. How is it, then, that this most unfitted of all races, according to commonly accepted ideas, could bear the most awful misfortunes that ever befall a race, and yet not show the least signs of decay? How is it that, while the multiplying powers of the so-called vigorous and active races are dwindling every day, the immoral (?) Hindu shows a power of increase beyond them all? Great laurels are due, no doubt, to those who can deluge the world with blood at a moment's notice; great indeed is the glory of those who, to keep up a population of a few millions in plenty, have to starve half the population of the earth, but is no credit due to those who can keep hundreds of millions in peace and plenty, without snatching the bread from the mouth of anyone else? Is there no power displayed in bringing up and guiding the destinies of countless millions of human beings, through hundreds of centuries, without the least violence to others?

The mythologists of all ancient races supply us with fables of heroes whose life was concentrated in a certain small portion of their bodies, and until that was touched they remained invulnerable. It seems as if each nation also has such a peculiar centre of life, and so long as that remains untouched, no amount of misery and misfortune can destroy it.

In religion lies the vitality of India,
and so long as the Hindu race do not forget the great inheritance of their forefathers, there is no power on earth to destroy them.

Nowadays everybody blames those who constantly look back to their past. It is said that so much looking back to the past is the cause of all India's woes. To me, on the contrary, it seems that the opposite is true. So long as they forgot the past, the Hindu nation remained in a state of stupor; and as soon as they have begun to look into their past, there is on every side a fresh manifestation of life. It is out of this past that the future has to be moulded; this past will become the future.


The more, therefore, the Hindus study the past, the more glorious will be their future, and whoever tries to bring the past to the door of everyone, is a great benefactor to his nation. The degeneration of India came not because the laws and customs of the ancients were bad, but because they were not allowed to be carried to their legitimate conclusions." 

(Excerpt from a letter written by Swami Vivekananda to Maharaja of Khetri, 1895. CWSV, Vol 4, pp 322-24, Mayawati Memorial Edition.)

Wednesday, 24 January 2018

Rani Padmavati - A Glorious History as recorded in our folklores

रानी पद्मावती - इतिहास का एक स्वर्णिम पृष्ठ, हमारी लोककथाओं से 


दिल्ली के सुल्तान अलाउद्दीन खिलजी के शासनकाल के दौरान मेवाड़ एक शक्तिशाली राजपूत राज्य था । मेवाड़ के राजा थे राणा रतन सिंह । चित्तौड़ का किला मेवाड़ का रक्षा कवच था । 700 एकड़ जमीन में फैला यह किला समय के प्रहारों के खिलाफ मजबूती से खड़ा रहा है |

रानी पद्मावती मनोहरगढ़ के राजा सम्मान सिंह जी पंवार की बेटी थी । राजा सम्मान सिंह ने अपनी बेटी के लिए एक स्वयम्वर की व्यवस्था की । राणा रतन सिंह ने मलखान सिंह (एक छोटे से पड़ोसी राज्य के राजा) को हराने के बाद पद्मावती से विवाह किया ।

अलाउद्दीन खिलजी ने अपने ससुर और चाचा जलालउद्दीन खिलजी की हत्या करने के बाद अपने आप को दिल्ली का सुल्तान घोषित कर दिया था। उसने रानी पद्मावती के सौन्दर्य के बारे में बहुत कुछ सुन रखा था । वह रानी को हर हाल में पाना चाहता था । जनवरी 1303 में अलाउद्दीन खिलजी ने एक विशाल सेना के साथ चित्तौड़ पर चढ़ाई कर दी । किले की मजबूत रक्षा व्यवस्था देखकर वह बहुत निराश हुआ ।

खिलजी की सेना की ताकत देखकर राणा रतन सिंह लड़ाई से बचने के उपाय सोचने लगे । तब अलाउद्दीन खिलजी ने राजा को एक सन्देश भेजा कि वह अपनी सेना के साथ दिल्ली लौट जाएंगे यदि राणा रानी पद्मावती की एक झलक की अनुमति दे दें |

पद्मावती इसके लिए एक शर्त पर सहमत हो गई कि खिलजी केवल एक आईने में उनका प्रतिबिम्ब देख सकता है । अलाउद्दीन खिलजी भी सहमत हो गया और वह अपने विश्वस्त जनरलों के साथ रानी को देखने आया । आईने में पद्मावती का प्रतिबिंब देखकर खिलजी हक्का-बक्का रह गया । जितना सुना था रानी पद्मावती उससे भी कहीं अधिक सुन्दर थीं । अब रानी को अपनाने की उसकी इच्छा उसमें और अधिक मजबूत हो गई ।

शर्त के अनुसार अलाउद्दीन खिलजी अपने शिविर की ओर रवाना हो गया । रतन सिंह खिलजी को किले के फाटक तक छोड़ने गए । फाटक पहुंचते ही खिलजी ने छल से रतन सिंह को बंधक बनाकर अपने शिविर ले गया और उन्हें कैद कर लिया | अब उसने चित्तौड़ किले में सन्देश भेज राजा के बदले रानी पद्मावती की मांग की ।

बुद्धिमत्ता पद्मावती ने एक योजना तैयार की । उसने खिलजी के पास एक दूत भेजा और कहा कि वह पालकी में अपनी सहेलीयों और नौकरानियों के साथ सुबह तक शिविर पहुँच जायेंगी । अगले दिन सुबह रानी ने सेना के दो प्रमुख जनरल ‘गोरा’ और ‘बादल’ के साथ कई सैनिकों को खिलजी के शिविर जाने के लिए तैयार किया । एक पालकी में गोरा खुद बैठ गए । हथियार सहित महिलाओं के वेश में कुछ सैनिक पालकीओं में बैठ गए और बाकी 200 सैनिक पालकीओं के वाहकों की भूमिका में खिलजी के शिविर की ओर चल दिए | शिविर में पहुंचते ही 80 साल के गोरा ने रतन सिंह के टेंट में जाकर उन्हें घोड़े पे बैठने को कहा और चित्तौडगढ़ किले की ओर जाने को कहा । एक तरफ राणा किले की ओर निकले और दूसरी तरफ राणा के सैनिकों ने खिलजी की सेना पर हमला बोल दिया । गोरा खिलजी के तम्बू तक पहुंचा और खिलजी को मारने ही वाला था पर सुल्तान अपनी उपपत्नी के पीछे छिप गया । भारत के योद्धा महिलाओं को नहीं मारते, इसलिए गोरा ने उस महिला पर वार नहीं किया और खिलजी बच गया |

इस मुठभेड में दोनों पक्ष के कई सैनिक मारे गये और राणा रतन सिंह को मुक्त कर लिया गया । खिलजी के सैनिकों से युद्ध करते हुए ‘गोरा’ और ‘बादल’ वीरगति को प्राप्त हुए । और राणा रतन सिंह चित्तौड़ के किले में सुरक्षित पहुँच गए |

इस पर क्रोधित अलाउद्दीन खिलजी ने चित्तौड़ किले को चारों ओर से घेर लिया | राणा रतन सिंह अपने सैनिकों को किले के सभी फाटक बंद रखने का आदेश दिया । खिलजी के सैनिक चित्तौड़ किला की मजबूत दीवारों को नहीं तोड़ पाए । यह सिलसिला आठ महीने तक चला (जनवरी से अगस्त तक) । किले में संग्रहित खाद्य वस्तुएं समाप्त होने लगीं | 26 अगस्त, 1303, को रतन सिंह ने अपनी सेना के साथ केसरी पगड़ी धारण करते हुए दुश्मनों के खिलाफ आत्मघाती हमला कर दिया । लड़ाई में रतन सिंह सहित सारे सैनिक मारे गए ।

राणा की मृत्यु का समाचार पाकर, पद्मावती ने किले के अन्दर एक विशाल चिता बनाई और रानी पद्मावती और उनके साथी ने क्रूर दुश्मन के हाथों अपने सम्मान को बचाने के लिए चिता में कूद गये ।

खिलजी और उनके सैनिक जब किले के अन्दर आये, तो उन्हे केवल राजपूत महिलाओं की राख ही मिली |

पद्मावती और उनके साथियों को उनके सर्वोच्च बलिदान के लिए हमारी श्रद्धांजलि ! गोरा और बादल की वीरता को नमन ।

( चित्तौड़गढ़ किले में रानी पद्मनी के महल के दक्षिण में दो गुम्बद के आकार के महल आज भी हैं जिन्हें 
गोरा-बादल के महल के नाम से जाना जाता है । )

आशा है कि फिल्म पदमावत में  रानी पद्मावती और उन 1600 राजपूतनियों, जिन्होंने अपने और देश के सम्मान की रक्षा करते हुए जौहर किया और गोरा और बादल की वीरता और स्वामिभक्ति के साथ न्याय किया होगा |

(Received on WhatsApp, Author unknown,  Edited) 

Also refer to: https://hi.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E0%A4%AA%E0%A4%A6%E0%A5%8D%E0%A4%AE%E0%A4%BF%E0%A4%A8%E0%A5%80


Monday, 22 January 2018

Rani Padmavati to Padmavat - I am hurt !

रानी पद्मावती से पद्मावत – मैं आहत हूँ !


पद्मावती कोई कपोल-कल्पना नहीं है, एक उपन्यास की निर्जीव पात्र नहीं है जिस पर कोई कुछ भी लिख दे या कह दे | पद्मावती हमारे इतिहास का एक गौरवमयी पृष्ठ है,  भारत का आदर्श है, उसके त्याग और साहस की पराकाष्ठा है, हमारी प्रेरणा का स्त्रोत है !

पद्मावती हमारी पूर्वज हैं, हमारी माता हैं, हमारा आदर्श हैं, हमारी शक्ति का स्त्रोत हैं |

कोई भी व्यक्ति केवल देह नहीं होता, वह एक आदर्श होता है, एक विचार होता है, जिसे वह अपने जीवन से व्यक्त करता है | व्यक्ति की देह नश्वर है, परन्तु उसका आदर्श और उसके विचार उसकी मृत्यु के पश्चात् भी जीवित रहते हैं इसी कारण उसके जाने के बाद भी हम उसे स्मरण करते हैं | और यदि किसी व्यक्ति का आदर्श उसके समाज के लिए गर्व का विषय हो तो समाज उसे अंगीकार कर लेता है, वह चिरजीवी हो जाता है | फिर हर वर्ष हम उसकी जयंती मनाते है | पद्मावती केवल एक देह नहीं जो मिट्टी में विलीन हो चुकी है, वह एक आदर्श है जो आज भी जीवत है, क्योंकि उसके आदर्श में समाज आज भी अपना आदर्श देखता है |

खिलजी के कारण पद्मावती और उनकी सहयोगी वीरान्गनाओं ने जब जौहर किया तब केवल उनके शरीर का अन्त हुआ था पर परन्तु उस जौहर-अग्नि से जिस आदर्श ने जन्म लिया वह सदा के लिए अमर हो गया | आज उस इतिहास को पलट कर अथवा उसका उपहास कर भंसाली ने खिलजी से भी अति गंभीर अपराध किया है | खिलजी ने पद्मावती का केवल शरीर छीना था परन्तु भंसाली उनके आदर्श की ह्त्या कर रहा है |

और यह केवल पद्मावती के आदर्श, और उसके विचार की ह्त्या नहीं है यह हमारे आदर्शों की ह्त्या है | यह हमारी माँ का अपमान हैं, हम इसे कैसे सह सकते हैं | यह हमारे देश का अपमान है | यह हमारी अस्मिता की ह्त्या है | यह हमारी संस्कृति और हमारी प्रेरणा की ह्त्या है, जिसका मूल्य हमारे प्राणों से कई गुना अधिक है | यह घोर अपराध हम सबके वध से भी कहीं अधिक गंभीर है | हम यह नहीं सह सकते, चाहे इसके लिए हमें अपनी आहूति ही क्यों न देनी पड़े |

यह कौन सा न्याय है जिसमें मानवीय मूल्यों, आदर्शों और प्रेरणा स्त्रोतों की कोई गणना नहीं है | जिसमें इतिहास का कोई महत्व नहीं है | जिसमें हमारी अस्मिता का भी कोई महत्त्व नहीं है | ऐसा लगता है भौतिक्तावाद की आंधी में हमारा न्याय भी दिक्भ्रमित हो गया है ? क्या एक व्यक्ति की सनक और पैसों की भूख को अभिव्यक्ति की आजादी का नाम देकर लाखों लोगों की आस्था का वध न्यायसंगत होगा? आज न्यायलय को अपने न्याय की अवधारण पर एक बार पुन: विचार करना होगा |

एक तर्क और दिया जा रहा है कि चलचित्र में जो कुछ भी है भी वह शोध पर आधारित है | यह भी कितना खोखला आधार है |
1)  इतिहास को कभी सिद्ध नहीं किया जा सकता, क्योंकि समय के साथ उसके प्रमाण समाप्त हो जाते हैं |

2)  इतिहास लिखने वाला सदा अपनी भावनाओं और श्रद्धा से उसे रंग देता है | उदाहरण के लिए महाराणा प्रताप और अकबर के हल्दी-घाटी के युद्ध में एक वर्ग यह मानता है कि महाराणा की विजय हुई थी, दूसरा यह कि अकबर की विजय हुई थी और एक तीसरा वर्ग भी है जो कहता है कि युद्ध अनिर्णीत रहा | यह तीनों ही निष्कर्ष अपनी जगह हैं और सत्य कभी उजागर नहीं होगा |

3)  श्रीकृष्ण से सम्बंधित द्वारिका, मथुरा, वृन्दावन, कुरुक्षेत्र, महाभारत और गीता इत्यादि आज भी विद्यमान हैं परन्तु फिर भी एक वर्ग है जो श्रीकृष्ण को केवल कवि की कल्पना मानता है |

4)  श्रीराम से सम्बंधित अयोध्या, चित्रकूट, लंका, रामसेतू, रमायण इत्यादि आज भी विद्यमान हैं परन्तु फिर भी एक वर्ग है जो इन्हें श्रीराम को भी कवि की कल्पना मानता है |

5)  राम-सेतू को जिसे प्राकृतिक संरचना मान कर नकारा जा रहा था आज नासा ने उसे मानवीय कृति घोषित कर दिया है | तो क्या कुछ वर्ष पूर्व जो लोग श्रीराम को कवि की कल्पना मानते थे, उनके विचार बदल गए ? ऐसा नहीं है क्योंकि वह कोई और तर्क ढूँढ़ लेंगे, उस निष्कर्ष को सिद्ध करने के लिए जिसे वह पाहिले ही मान चुके हैं | तर्कों से कुछ सिद्ध नहीं होता वह केवल अपने मन के द्वन्द को शान्त करने का उपाय है | जिसे जो ठीक लगता है उसी के अनुरूप तर्क चुन लेता है | 


भारत का इतिहास अति प्राचीन है | तब आज जैसे पन्ने नहीं होते थे और न ही इतिहास को ज्यों का त्यों रखने की तकनीकी थी | तब भारत में इतिहास काव्यों में और लोक-कथाओं में संजो कर रखा जाता था | इन कथाओं के अलग अलग रचयिता अलग-अलग प्रकार से इतिहास को कहते थे | पश्चिम देशों के विपरीत भारत इतिहास की घटनाओं और उनके विवरण को नहीं अपितु उसकी भावनाओं, आदर्शों और संदेशों को संजो कर रखता था | जो न केवल समाज के मोरंजन का साधन था अपितु उसके जीवन में अभीष्ट आदर्शों का निर्माण करता था और उसमें एकता का भाव पैदा करता था | उदाहरण के लिए रामचरितमानस न केवल जन-जन का मनोरंजन करती है उनमें उच्च आदर्शों का भी सृजन करती है | 

इतिहास के इस उद्देश्य को समझ कर आज के काल में भी इतिहास को एक दूसरे रूप में लिखा जा सकता है | परन्तु यदि उसकी मूल भावना को आहत अथवा नष्ट किया जाता है तो उसे स्वीकार नही किया जाना चाहिए | उदाहरण के लिए महाराणा प्रताप और अकबर के युद्ध से कोई यह निष्कर्ष निकालने का प्रयास करे की महाराणा युद्ध से घबरा कर मैदान छोड़ कर भाग गए, तो यह कभी स्वीकार नहीं हो सकता | यह महराणा प्रताप और देश का अपमान होगा | इसलिए जब तक अकाट्य प्रमाण न हों इतिहास से छेड़-छाड़ नहीं होनी चाहिए | और यदि हमें किसी प्रकरण की पुनर्कल्पना ही करनी है तो वह इस प्रकार की जाए कि उसके आदशों की ह्त्या अथवा अपमान न हो; और उसे और अधिक उन्नत आदर्शों से महिमा मंडित किया जाए | जिससे वह समाज को एक न केवल दिशा दे सके अपितु उसके उत्थान में भी सहायक हो |  

कुछ प्रश्न भंसाली जी पर भी उठते हैं –
1) क्या भंसाली अपनी माता, बहिन अथवा अपने पूर्वजों पर किसी भी प्रकार की फिल्म बनाने की अनुमति देंगे ?

2) क्या उनके पास और कोई कहानी नहीं हैं जो वह इतिहास को दूषित करना चाहते हैं ?

3) क्या उनमें यह सामर्थ्य नहीं कि वह विवाद खड़ा किए बिना अपनी फिल्म दर्शकों को बेच सकें ?

4) क्या उनके लिए धन के सामने आदर्शों, मान-अपमान, प्रेरणाओं का कोई अर्थ नहीं है ?

5) क्या वे इतने अक्षम और निर्धन हैं कि देश की संकृति को बेच कर धन कमाना चाह रहे हैं ?

6) क्या एक व्यापारी इतना गिर गया है कि वह पैसे के लिए देश का इतिहास बेच रहा है ?


किसी एक व्यक्ति को अभिव्यक्ति की आजादी के नाम पर यह अधिकार कौन देता है कि वह देश के आदर्शों का अपमान करे, वह भी कुछ चाँद रुपयों के लिए |   

क्या यह संभव है कि
1) भंसाली जी को इस फिल्म की लागत दे कर उनसे इस फिल्म को खरीद लिया जाए और फिर उसे प्रदर्शन से रोक लिया जाए?

2) या फिर राष्ट्रपति के समक्ष इसे रोकने का आवेदन किया जाए?

3) या फिर माननीय न्यायलय, सेंसर-बोर्ड और कुछ प्रबुद्ध लोग उसे देख कर देश को यह विश्वास दिलाएं कि यह फिल्म देश के आदर्शों को आहत नहीं करती ? क्यों नहीं न्यायलय कुछ दिन और रुक सकता | यदि सभी पक्षों को सुन लिया जाए और उसमें कुछ माह लग भी जाएं तो भंसाली जी की क्या हानि हो जाएगी | क्या यह मामला केवल किसी के व्यापार का है, व्यापार में लाभ-हानि का है ? यह प्रकरण इतना छोटा नहीं है जितना इसे आंका जा रहा है, यह देश के सम्मान का विषय है|


मैं आहत हूँ | देश की रक्षा का अर्थ केवल उसकी सीमाओं की रक्षा ही नहीं है जिसके लिए हर वर्ष हजारों वीर प्राणों का बलिदान करते हैं | देश की रक्षा का अर्थ यह भी है कि उसके सम्मान और आदर्शों की भी रक्षा की जाए | 

कहीं भारत माता एक और 'जौहर' का आवाहन तो नहीं कर रहीं ?